Top Horror Games for PS4: Must-Play Scary Titles for 2025

It’s that time of year again—spooky season is in full swing, and there’s no better way to get into the Halloween spirit than by playing some of the top horror games for PS4. Whether you’re in the mood for a slow-burn psychological thriller or a multiplayer scare-fest with friends, there’s something on this list for everyone. We’ve picked out the latest and greatest scary games for 2025, including a few classics that still pack a punch. No need to rank them—just find a few that sound good to you and start playing. Grab a blanket, turn off the lights, and get ready for some frights.

Key Takeaways

• The PS4 library is packed with both new and classic horror games, perfect for 2025’s spooky season.
• You’ll find a mix of solo adventures and multiplayer scares, so there’s something for every kind of horror fan.
• Recent releases like Alan Wake 2 and Still Wakes the Deep bring fresh scares, while old favorites like Until Dawn still hold up.
• Games like Phasmophobia and The Outlast Trials are great for playing with friends, mixing in some laughs with the screams.
• Whether you want survival horror, psychological chills, or just a good jump scare, these top horror games for PS4 have you covered.

1. Alan Wake 2

It’s wild to think that after all these years, Alan Wake 2 finally landed on PlayStation, and for a lot of us horror fans, it just nails what makes the genre so gripping. Alan Wake 2 fuses suspenseful storytelling with gameplay that genuinely messes with your head. You don’t have to play the first game to jump in, but if you did, there’s a bunch of new twists to mess with your expectations.

You’re going back and forth between two characters—Alan Wake himself, a writer lost in nightmare scenarios, and Saga Anderson, an FBI agent pulling at threads of a murder mystery. Their stories smash together in all sorts of mind-bending, weird places, so you’re never quite sure what’s real. The cutscenes blend into the action so smoothly, swerving between reality and these creepy dream sequences that keep you guessing.

Here’s what stands out:

• Spooky, unpredictable settings that constantly change as the story unravels, making you second-guess every shadow.
• Combat that rewards figuring out enemy patterns—less run-and-gun, more using light and your wits.
• Puzzles that are actually satisfying, with clues hidden in the environment and journal entries that feel like reading parts of a horror novel.

If you like great music in your games, Alan Wake 2 delivers with a moody soundtrack put together by an amazing Scandinavian rock band. Even the smallest details, like the flicker of a flashlight in the woods, somehow ramp up the dread.

People sometimes ask if it’s better to play it on newer consoles, but the PS4 version holds up surprisingly well, even as the Xbox 360 ends its run. Alan Wake 2 really is a must for anyone who loves survival horror, clever stories, or just wants a good scare as the nights get longer this fall.

2. Still Wakes the Deep

If you like your horror with a good helping of atmosphere, Still Wakes the Deep is a can’t-miss pick. The story puts you in the shoes of Caz, an electrician working on the Beira D oil rig in the North Sea, set during the 1970s. After an accident shakes up the rig, things get weird fast. There’s a supernatural twist that creeps in, and you’re stuck trying to get the rig back online while something stalks you through the tight spaces and dark hallways.

The voice acting really nails that sense of dreary, everyday life interrupted by something horrible. Fans have mentioned how the mix of realism and Lovecraft-inspired horror in the narrative really helps make everything feel more personal. If you want more on the story’s themes, it’s definitely worth checking out. The game manages to make the oil rig itself feel like a character—cold, isolated, and sometimes more threatening than whatever monster might be loose.

Some points that stand out:

• The game creates a constant sense of tension—you never feel safe.
• It’s not overly long; you can finish it over a weekend, but it leaves a mark.
• Although the puzzles are simple, that helps the pacing and never gets too distracting.

Honestly, I found the guided approach a little bit too much at times, but if you’re more interested in being scared than getting lost, it works in your favor. Still Wakes the Deep is great for anyone who wants quality storytelling, scary moments, and just a bit of old-fashioned disaster survival. Not your average jump-scare fest—it sticks with you, which is rare these days.

3. Silent Hill 2 Remake

Silent Hill 2 Remake is back, and honestly, it feels both familiar and brand new all at once. The folks at Bloober Team really took on a tall order with this one. They’ve managed to keep a lot of what made people obsessed with the original, while still updating things so it doesn’t just feel like a relic from the early 2000s. The creepiness and tension feel alive again thanks to those updated visuals and chilling sound design that pretty much had my nerves shot the whole time.

A lot of the magic here is in the details:

• Locations look like you remember them in your nightmares, but way sharper, thanks to the new engine and attention to weather effects. The fog feels like it’s got a life of its own.
• Cutscenes got a major boost from the new cast, and they really manage to sell the feeling of dread. It’s not just old lines regurgitated—there’s actually some fresh drama in there.
• Puzzles are tough but satisfying. It’s not the sort of thing you can just breeze through; they require real thought, just like the classic.

Here’s a quick comparison of a few key changes:

I should also mention, it won’t please the super hardcore purists—some things have changed just enough to rattle people who wanted a frame-by-frame redo. But for new players, or folks who want a reason to revisit foggy streets, it’s the perfect entry point. If you want to keep your saved progress safe as you test out nightmares, backing up your save files on your PS4 is a smart move; it’s a simple way to protect your data. Bottom line: don’t play this alone unless you really want to sleep with the lights on.

4. Resident Evil Village

Resident Evil Village really kept me on the edge of my seat the first time I played it. Picking up after the story of Ethan Winters from Resident Evil 7, you get thrown right into a weird, snow-covered European village that’s crawling with things you definitely don’t want to bump into at night—or in the day, honestly. The mix of a twisted fairytale vibe, unpredictable monsters around the next corner, and moments that make you question if you actually want to keep your lights off, make this one unforgettable.

Some of the highlights that stand out:

• The main villain, Lady Dimitrescu, seriously took the internet by storm and made every castle hallway tense.
• Exploration is nerve-wracking but rewarding; hidden items and weird puzzles kept me scanning every nook.
• Weapons and upgrades are fun to hunt down, and sometimes necessary for staying alive.
• The environments go from creepy villages to a downright disturbing dollhouse—nothing feels safe for long.

Here’s a quick breakdown of how people rate Resident Evil Village:

Overall, it’s one of those games you finish, and then sit staring at the screen for a bit, unsure if you’ll ever be able to look at creepy village settings the same way again. Definitely not one to play alone with headphones late at night—trust me.

5. Little Nightmares 3

Little Nightmares 3 is making a return just as Halloween 2025 rolls around, set for release on October 10. This entry shifts the development torch to Supermassive Games, known for their reputation in horror gaming, after Tarsier Studios moved on. If you’ve followed the series, you already know it does tension and scares really well by putting you in the shoes of tiny characters lost in a huge, menacing world. This time, you’ll play as Low and Alone, two new survivors trying to escape the dangerous setting of Necropolis and places beyond.

Here’s what stands out:

• Two-player co-op lets you experience scares together (or argue when someone misses a jump).
• New settings and storylines mean fresh puzzles and monsters.
• Supermassive’s horror style adds those nerve-wracking moments fans crave.

Past games thrived on atmosphere, with shadowy visuals and eerie sound design, but the addition of actual co-op in Little Nightmares 3 should shake things up for both returning and new players. It’s designed for all the major platforms—including PS4—so it’s accessible for pretty much anyone.

If you care about timing your horror fixes for Halloween, this is one to put on your calendar, especially since the spooky season usually marks the arrival of big horror releases including tech advances like those seen during the Oculus Rift’s launch. Expect the same gnawing sense of dread as earlier entries, plus a little more chaos as you and a friend figure it all out together.

6. Dying Light: The Beast

Dying Light: The Beast picks up old threads but turns them on their head. This time, you explore Castor Woods, a whole new setting that’s more forests and fog than city rooftops. You’re back in Kyle Crane’s battered shoes, only now he’s been poked and prodded by scientists for years—he’s not the same guy from the last time around.

The real draw here is just how tense and creepy things get after dark. When night falls, don’t be surprised if you’re sprinting for your life, barely dodging things that want to rip your face off. Parkour is smoother, the layout is way more vertical, and you have to pay attention to those tiny details just to survive. It’s less about shooting and more about smart movement and timing your runs — ammo is rare, so you’re picking up pipes and whatever else just to smash your way through.

Here’s what makes Dying Light: The Beast worth your nerves:

• A bigger focus on horror, with night sequences that feel straight out of a nightmare.
• Tons of new parkour paths and tricks — trees, towers, even abandoned ski lifts.
• Weapons? They’re all about getting creative — bats, blades, electrified bits of whatever you find lying around.
• The open world is packed with secrets, but also, if you wander at night, you’re rolling the dice every time.

If you’re the type who likes to stack up stats, you’ll see these changes from past games:

Some bugs still sneak through, and the voice acting turns a bit cheesy in places—but Dying Light: The Beast throws you into a world where you never, ever feel safe. At its core, that’s what horror games are all about.

7. Phasmophobia

Ghost hunting is way scarier when you’re squabbling over a spirit box in a dark hallway with your friends, trust me. Phasmophobia throws you and up to three buddies into haunted houses, schools, prisons—you name it—and asks you to find out what’s lurking in the shadows. It’s been around since 2020 but launched on PS4 in late 2024, and it’s still hanging on to its popularity because of steady updates and its seriously creepy atmosphere.

You all play as amateur ghost hunters, using gadgets like EMF readers and thermometers to gather evidence. The ghost isn’t there for laughs, either—it reacts to your voice, tries to separate the team, and can turn a routine check into a horror show without warning.

I think the coolest part is the teamwork. If you’re a scaredy cat, you can hang back on the van’s cameras, or if you’re the brave one, you get stuck with the spirit box in a pitch-black basement. You never really know what’s coming, and the game doesn’t give you time to get comfy.

Some things that make Phasmophobia a standout:

• In-game voice chat that actually matters. Say the wrong thing? The ghost might hear you.
• Varied haunted locations, each with different ghost types and ways to investigate.
• New updates and seasonal events that regularly shake things up, so even hardcore players stay interested.

Here’s a quick rundown for PS4:

Having played it during a stormy night, I can confirm: no game gets the whole group yelling and laughing like Phasmophobia does.

8. Amnesia: The Bunker

Amnesia: The Bunker is the kind of horror game that makes you always check over your shoulder, even after you’ve turned off your PS4. Set in a chilling World War I underground shelter, you’re dropped smack in the middle of tight corridors, flickering lights, and a lot of uncertainty about what’s lurking just out of sight. The biggest threat is The Beast, a monster that stalks you with unpredictable patterns – sometimes bursting through walls, other times just scraping along in the shadows.

One thing that makes this title stand out is the way every playthrough feels different. The monster doesn’t always behave the same way, so you can’t memorize its movements. That makes each game uniquely tense. You’ve got very limited resources, too—a single bullet, a pocketful of rags, and whatever scraps you pick up in the darkness. Managing supplies is stressful, to say the least.

Key challenges you’ll face in the bunker:

• Searching for parts to fix the generator, or you risk being totally trapped in the dark.
• Scrounging for items to craft tools or bandages, because you won’t survive long without them.
• Figuring out the layout and solving the bunker’s puzzles before the Beast tracks you down.

Here’s a quick look at a few core survival elements in Amnesia: The Bunker:

If you like horror games that keep you guessing, this one’s top notch. The WWII setting mixes with supernatural scares in a way that’s rarely done this well. And while it’s definitely not easy, it’s incredibly satisfying when you finally make it out alive. For anyone who’s played classic survival horror on lower-spec systems, you might be familiar with laptop-friendly games with a punch, but Amnesia: The Bunker cranks the fear up to eleven and refuses to let go until the final credits roll.

9. The Outlast Trials

The Outlast Trials turns up the intensity for fans of first-person horror, but there’s a twist: this time, you can face the terror with friends. Instead of going solo and creeping through empty corridors, you’re now part of a group trying to survive nightmarish experiments together. The setup is pretty wild—you’re unwitting test subjects for a shady Cold War-era program, doing everything possible to escape while dodging some truly twisted enemies like Sergeant Coyle and Mother Gooseberry.

If you’ve played earlier Outlast games, you know to expect some shocking moments, but Trials mixes things up with co-op play. It gets even better when your squad has to solve puzzles or split up to complete different tasks, which means more chances for things to go horribly (and hilariously) wrong. The scares can go from tense and quiet to total chaos in seconds, especially if someone in your group panics and blows your cover.

A few key things that stand out:

• Up to four players can tackle the trials together, or you can go alone if you really want a challenge.
• Each mission offers different objectives, so it doesn’t feel repetitive.
• Cosmetic unlocks and a progression system give you reasons to keep coming back.

If you’re curious about how The Outlast Trials shakes up the series, the recent Deep Burn event gameplay trailer gives you a look at the action and just how wild things can get. It’s best with friends, but don’t be fooled—even with backup, you’ll need nerves of steel (and probably someone willing to open the next creepy door).

10. Until Dawn

Until Dawn is one of those titles that’s perfect if you enjoy gathering friends and getting a little spooked together. The game puts you in charge of a group of teens caught in a remote mountain cabin, with the sort of setup that immediately screams trouble. Things quickly go sideways, and the only real question is—who’s going to make it out alive?

Your choices really do matter in Until Dawn—decisions lead directly to life-or-death results for each character, and you’ll often be surprised at how things work out. Because you’re swapping between different characters throughout, the story feels fast, and there are always fresh twists to keep you guessing. This setup means the game can be just as much fun to play solo in the dark as it is during a party night with friends, passing the controller and trying to keep your favorite characters breathing.

Here are a few stand-out reasons Until Dawn remains a favorite:

• Loads of replay value since outcomes shift with your choices
• A memorable cast and voice acting that brings everyone to life
• Surprises that genuinely catch you off guard, even if you think you know horror

Of course, it isn’t perfect. While the visuals and sound design are fantastic, some players have noticed minor framerate issues that can be a little distracting during busy scenes. Still, these are small bumps in what’s overall a wild, scary experience.

If you’re craving a slasher story where you get to pull the strings—and maybe yell at your friends about their questionable decisions—Until Dawn is still a must-have for the PS4 in 2025.

Wrapping Up: The Best Horror Games for PS4 in 2025

So there you have it—a big batch of horror games to keep you busy (and maybe a little jumpy) this spooky season. Whether you’re into classic survival horror, creepy solo adventures, or you just want to scream with your friends in a multiplayer session, there’s something here for everyone. I always find myself coming back to these games when the nights get longer and colder. And honestly, there’s nothing quite like turning off the lights, grabbing some snacks, and letting a good horror game mess with your head. If you haven’t tried a few of these yet, now’s the perfect time. Who knows, you might even find a new favorite to play every Halloween. Happy haunting!

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s the scariest horror game for PS4 in 2025?

Many players say ‘Still Wakes the Deep’ is the scariest horror game for PS4 in 2025. Its creepy setting on an oil rig and the feeling of being trapped with something terrifying makes it stand out among the rest.

Are these horror games good to play with friends?

Some of these games are great for playing with friends! For example, ‘Phasmophobia’ and ‘The Outlast Trials’ have multiplayer modes where you and your friends can team up to face scary challenges together.

Which horror game is best for beginners?

If you’re new to horror games, ‘Little Nightmares 3’ is a good place to start. It’s spooky but not too intense, and its puzzles and story are easy to follow.

Do I need to play earlier games in the series before trying these titles?

Not always. Games like ‘Alan Wake 2’ and ‘Silent Hill 2 Remake’ are sequels or remakes, but you can enjoy them even if you haven’t played the earlier games. Some background knowledge might help, but it’s not required.

Are these games suitable for younger players?

Most of these horror games are made for older teens and adults because they have scary themes, violence, and sometimes disturbing scenes. It’s best for younger players to check the game’s rating before playing.

Can I play all these games on PS4?

Most of the games on this list are available on PS4, but a few might only be on newer consoles or PC. Always check the game’s platform before buying to make sure it works on your system.